She was born in 1836 in Warren, Ohio, as Elvira Scott, as she indicated on her marriage certificate in 1854 in Illinois.

There were no birth records there in Ohio until 1867. On an 1860 US Census after marrying she indicated her father was born on Long Island, and her mother was born in Pennsylvania.

How can I solve this mystery?

1 Answer 1


You have a great question that many genealogists run into. Where can I find XXXX?

1st I would not trust a Census except for the existence of a person. Many if not most have many errors in them, age, birth place, relationship to head, spelling just to name a few. If over many Censuses all the information is the same, it might be trustworthy.

I would try church records. Then I would try historical societies. Libraries but most of their information is not catalogued unless in books.

Did any of your deceased relatives have any genealogy records? I was fortunate that both my father and my grandmother (mother's mother) had done a fair bit of research. However, not much on the branches of the family I am researching, but very useful information. Ask family members, cousins, distant cousins and anyone who was close to your family if anybody had done any research. Hopefully you will be surprised and find some.

I would also look on genealogical sites to see if someone had your relative in their tree.

I'm sure I will remember more just as soon as I post this. Good Luck

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge that you have read and understand our privacy policy and code of conduct.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.