3

In searching for an ancestor I googled and found ancestry.com trees. On those trees I found citations to 'World Family Tree Vol. 1, Ed. 1'. Is this a valid secondary source or is this just effectively citing mostly unsourced ancestry.com trees?

  • It is just effectively citing unsourced junkology- might as well cite OneWorldTree. – Andy Hatchett May 10 '13 at 0:04
  • 3
    World Family Tree is a geneathology. I wrote an entire article adressing this particular question: tamurajones.net/GenealogyWithoutDocumentationIsMythology.xhtml Here's a key quote: "Citing a geneathology does not a genealogy make. Citing a geneathology makes another geneathology.". – TamuraJones May 10 '13 at 9:23
8

Brøderbund Software were early publishers of Family Tree Maker which was sold supported by CDs of public genealogy data. I strongly suspect that you would be citing unsourced trees based on more unsourced trees if you relied on this source.

In any case, unless you have actually seen the source, genealogy good practice would say that you shouldn't cite it at all. "Cite what YOU see": so you could cite the ancestry trees which you have seen (if you judge them worth citing), but not the sources they cite.

| improve this answer | |
2

The World Family Tree files are User Created. As was mentioned, watch for Source material. I do NOT use them, unless I am looking for some hint into an ancestor that I can NOT find anywhere else.

These WFT are both Online at Genealogy.com and on CDs

| improve this answer | |
1

The quality of the trees in these archives varies greatly depending on the amount of effort the contributor put into creating the tree. There are source citations in many of them that are accurate while others are full of inaccuracies and propagate well known errors. They are best used as a hint to help you locate valid sources but if you include notes made by the contributor, it is only fair to cite the source for those notes and stories.

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.